Who Should Buy It?

Someone in need of a streamlined or more efficient/fun way to manage and edit pictures.

the Cost

$99 upgrade; $299 full license

the Good

Non-destructive local editing using a brush, dual monitor support, support for larger images.

the Bad

Speed when using certain settings, new features brings a new learning curve.

Adobe Lightroom is hands-down the most commonly used program on my computer when it comes to photography. So, it was an easy to decision to upgrade to version 2 when it came out earlier this week. I’ve had an opportunity to use it and have some initial feedback on what I like and what could have turned out better.

Also, check out the following links for more information on what’s new or for training resources.

Adobe Documentation

Training Support Center

My Favorite 6 New Features

The best news is that there are a TON of new, really great features. The core around many of these new features is reducing the need to go to Photoshop. 3 of my top 6 new favorite features eliminated the need to go to Photoshop – I can now do those things directly in Lightroom. That results in a big time saver.

1. Adjustment brush: The adjustment brush allows you to make non-destructive edits to just parts of your photo directly in Lightroom! Version 1 required that you make your adjustments to the whole picture – you needed to go to Photoshop to do anything to parts of the picture. This one feature nearly doubles my productivity. Also, Adobe did a good job implementing it (for the most part). The brush is natural and easy to use. It’s also very smart. When brushing the image, it can detect edges and only apply the adjustments to the areas it is supposed to. Very cool!
2. Open files in Photoshop without saving them: This is the #2 reason I upgraded. I do a fair amount of HDR and panorma shots – in the past when I needed to open several images to create one larger one, it saved each of the shots as a Photoshop file, even though I only needed one final pano. It resulted in tons of extra files (that were pretty large) filling up my hard drive. Well, no longer! No, you can open an image in Photoshop without having it automatically save it.
3. Larger file support (65,000 pixels): Previously, Lightroom would only store an image up to 10,000 pixels wide. That caused some major issues when stitching together multiple large images, which could result in at least 15,000-20,000 pixel widths. Now, Lightroom supports much larger file sizes – horray!
4. Print to JPEG: The Print area of Lightroom is so much fun to use. Printing is easy and highly configurable. One of the things I really liked in Lightroom 1 is creating fine art prints (prints that don’t fill the whole sheet and often have descriptive text or logos directly below them). Now, it’s even better. You can export those fine art prints, or anything else from the Print area to an image! That’ll make creating images for posting on this blog and in other areas much easier. I used to have to go to Photoshop to be able to do that.
5. Better sharpening: The sharpening section now includes all the same sliders as Photoshop, plus one or two extras. I used to pull almost every final image over to Photoshop for final sharpening. Not anymore! Lightroom can handle it all. It even applies some basic sharpening while exporting.
6. Dual monitor support: I can finally open up various parts of Lightroom on a second monitor, like the Grid view of all my pictures.

A few other nice things include: You can print picture packages, mixing multiple sizes of the same image onto a single page for printing; it upgrades well from Lightroom 1 – it pulled over all my pictures, settings, presets, etc.; you can save your print settings with your photos so that you can more quickly make reprints; better visual cues – for example, when you reject a photo, it now grays them out; vignettes that are based on the cropped part of the image (the old way would display the vignette on cropped out areas of the image, making it unusable in those cases); you can access collections (groups of photos) from the develop and output modules now, reducing the need to go back to the library just to choose a different set of photos to work on.

The Bad

The great new features definately make it worth the upgrade. There are, however, a few things that are causing me some heartache.

1. Adjustment brush speed: I usually like to check the setting that automatically writes any changes to the file directly into the file. In the past, that would slow things down a bit (it is faster for Lightroom to keep track of those changes instead of writing them into the file), but it was tolerable. With that setting checked the adjustment brush is almost unusable – it runs ridiculously slowly, forcing me to turn off that feature.
2. Sub collection creation : I use collections a ton – in fact, I create one collection with several sub collections on every one of my shoots. For some unexplainable reason, Lightroom made it a whole lot harder to create sub-collections.

The Final Word – Should You Buy It?

In some cases, product upgrades may not bring features that are applicable enough for everyone to warrant widespread upgrades. That is not the case for Lightroom 2, though. If you are a Lightroom 1 user (or just want to try it out), I would recommend purchasing Lightroom 2 without hesitation. The adjustment brush and better Photoshop support make this worth the upgrade all by themselves.

Stay tuned over the coming days and months for posts on how I use particular features.